Google has received a boost in its patent infringement dispute with Oracle over the use of Java in Android, after a US judge suggested that Google should not have to pay anywhere near the $2.6bn Oracle is demanding.
A US Federal court hearing last week heard that Google rejected the chance to pay Sun Microsystems $100m to use the Java platform when it was developing the Android operating system.
This revelation could be a significant blow to Oracle, as the firm had been banking on getting a settlement of between $2.6bn and $6bn.
US district judge William Alsup has now asked Oracle to revise its damages report, noting that, even if Java is a critical component of Android, it does not justify application of the entire market value rule.
"Given the presence in this case of a real-world ‘comparable' close on point - the last Sun offer in 2006 - the court is strongly of the view that the hypothetical negotiation should take that $100m offer as the starting point," he said.
"Wheels are critical to an automobile, but no one would apportion all of the demand for a car to just the wheels. It seems highly unlikely that Android derives its entire value from a small set of infringing features, given its breadth."
Judge Alsup did, however, warn Google about its conduct in the matter, and suggested that there is still a strong possibility of Oracle winning an injunction.
"Google may have simply been brazen, preferring to roll the dice on possible litigation rather than to pay a fair price," he said.
"There is a substantial possibility that a permanent injunction will be granted in the event that infringement is found, especially if willfulness is proven."
Florian Mueller, a software patents specialist, argued that Oracle faces an uphill battle to secure a multi-billion dollar settlement.
"[The] profitability of this for Oracle may now depend mostly on the question of whether or not the court grants an injunction, which is increasingly a possibility given what the judge said at a hearing on Thursday," he said in the Foss Patents Blog.
"With an injunction, Oracle would have the leverage to negotiate a licensing deal [with Google] that could result in a very high per-unit royalty."
A trial date is set for October, and Oracle's revised damages claim is due 35 days before the final pre-trial conference.
Cotton seedling freezes to death as Chang'e-4 shuts down for the Moon's 14-day lunar night
Fortnite easily out-earns PUBG, Assassin's Creed Odyssey and Red Dead Redemption 2 in 2018
Meteor showers as a service will be visible for about 100 kilometres in all directions
Saturn's rings only formed in the past 100 million years, suggests analysis of Cassini space probe data
New findings contradict conventional belief that Saturn's rings were formed along with the planet about 4.5 billion years ago