Prosecutors in the
Pirate
Bay trial have finished their closing arguments, and requested jail terms of
12 months apiece for the four men who run the torrent search site.
In his closing arguments prosecutor Håkan Roswall asked the court to sentence
the four defendants to one-year jail terms, half the maximum sentence, for
breaking copyright law. He argued that, although the site did not contain
pirated material, it was nevertheless a facilitator to piracy.
"A person who is holding someone's coat while they assault someone else is
complicit in the crime," he said, according to Swedish paper The
Local.
Roswall estimated that the site brought in over $1m (£709m) a year in
advertising revenue, and is a business rather than a hobby site. As such, stiff
penalties were needed.
Svartholm Warg, one of the defendants, questioned the revenue figure. "It is
totally absurd. Those numbers are totally disconnected from reality," he told
the TT news agency. "I was actually surprised that he's only asking for one
year. I'd expected two."
Roswall acknowledged the defence argument that the EU directive on e-commerce
states that web sites are not responsible for information transferred through
their domains, but maintained that an EU ruling was not needed in this case.
"It does not mean some sort of immunity for middlemen. And there is no reason
to request an opinion from the European Court," he stated.
The site's operators, Fredrik Neij, Gottfrid Svartholm Warg, Peter Sunde and
Carl Lundström, also face a demand for $12.7m (£9m) in damages.
Do you agree?
Have your say on this article