Samsung has dropped its $5.85bn bid for SanDisk following the memory card
vendor's disappointing financial results and its new agreement with Samsung
competitor Toshiba.
"Your surprise announcements of a quarter billion dollar operating loss, a
hurried recognition of your relationship with Toshiba and major job losses
across your organisation all point to a considerable increase in your risk
profile," said Samsung Electronics chief executive Yoon Woo Lee in an official
letter addressed to SanDisk executives.
On Monday, SanDisk announced that third-quarter revenue had slumped 21 per
cent since last year. To reduce its capital commitments in 2009, the company
signed an agreement in which Toshiba would take over 30 per cent of the parties'
joint manufacturing ventures.
SanDisk had also just turned down Samsung's offer of $26 a share, claiming
that it undervalued its long-term prospects.
Gartner analyst Joseph Unsworth suggested that Samsung's rejection of the
offer was due to SanDisk's financial condition rather than the over-supply in
the market for Nand Flash memory, affecting Samsung's market position and
economic prospects.
Nand Flash memory forms the core of removable storage devices known as USB
drives and most memory card formats.
"The over-supply is a known fact and not new," said Unsworth. "Samsung has
actually got what it wants. It has managed to get Toshiba to chip in and
increase its exposure to Flash."
But Unsworth noted that Samsung had still not sorted out the $50m royalty
payment it continues to pay to SanDisk each year, due to expire in August 2009.
"It has a 40 per take in the market and it cannot afford to let it expire," he
explained.
The expensive financial obligation was one of the main drivers for Samsung to
acquire SanDisk in the first place, argued Unsworth.
Do you agree?
Have your say on this article