Virtual tree giveaway a 'ridiculous attempt to gain credibility'
vnunet.com, 24 Apr 2007
Dell has come under heavy fire for a promotion of its Plant a Tree for Me environmental programme in the Second Life virtual world.
As vnunet.com's Silicon Valley Sleuth blog reported last week, Dell is giving away free 'virtual trees' which Second Life users can plant on private land and determine the pace at which they grow.
In a posting on a company blog, the computer maker marketed the event as an "expansion of Dell's Plant a Tree for Me programme in Second Life".
Dell's real world promotion solicits donations from buyers to plant trees so that the the tree's oxygen production offsets some of the carbon dioxide emissions caused during the manufacturing and use of the system.
Contrary to Dell's assertions, the virtual tree planting does not help reduce carbon emissions.
The Second Life tree is essentially a software application that requires computing power to grow and show up in the virtual world, thereby increasing Second Life's carbon emissions.
IT author Nicholas Carr has previously calculated that active Second Life players consume as much as 1,752kWh on a yearly basis, ranking the game only slightly below the average power consumption of the residents of Brazil.
Dell's attempt to advertise the virtual tree giveaway as environmentally safe has not impressed people in the blogosphere.
A poster on the Moonbattery blog claimed that Dell's move is "an indication that environmentalism's divorce from reality is now nearly complete".
Analyst firm TechDirt commented on its blog: "We have seen companies make some pretty ridiculous attempts to gain credibility by doing something in Second Life, but this one has to take the 'cake'."
In a comment on the Silicon Valley Sleuth blog, a Dell employee by the name of Laura Thomas said that the company did not intend for the promotion to be deceptive.
"The intention of the virtual trees and the party was to increase awareness of the real life Plant a Tree for Me programme, not to increase [Second Life creator] Linden Lab's energy consumption."
Firm plans to plant trees to offset carbon emissions from its computers
Nicholas Carr suggests avatars consume as much electricity as the real residents of South American country
Dixons group follows Dell's lead
Internet portal aims to offset all carbon emissions
First Looks Editor Ian Williams gets hands on with the Sony Ericsson Xperia X1
Do you agree?
Have your say on this article