Nintendo
has been hauled before the
Advertising
Standards Authority (ASA) after 17 TV viewers claimed that an advert for the
firm's Wii
console was "violent, offensive and disturbing".
The controversy was sparked by a Wii commercial that showed people of various
ages playing different computer games and performing actions such as boxing,
bowling, playing golf, bursting balloons, fishing and shooting.
One scene involved a man playing a game using the hand controller as a gun
and a sword. The text '16+' appeared on-screen and the ad cut between the player
and the on-screen gaming action.
However, when the player waved the controller his on-screen character slashed
his opponent several times. As he struck a final blow with the controller, the
on-screen opponent fell to the floor clutching his head.
Seven complainants found the "depiction of violence in the ad offensive and
disturbing". One viewer stated that it was reminiscent of recent videos released
by hostage-takers in Iraq.
An additional four complainants believed that the ad glorified violence and
the use of weapons, and could encourage children to emulate such actions.
Six complainants challenged the scheduling restrictions and said that the ad
should not be shown when children were watching TV.
The ad was cleared by the
Broadcast
Advertising Clearance Centre with an 'ex-kids' restriction, which meant that
it should not be shown in or around programmes made for, or specifically
targeted at, children.
Advertising agency
Leo
Burnett responded on behalf of Nintendo explaining that one of the games
featured in the ad, Legend of Zelda, was set in a fantasy world similar
to that in the popular film Lord of the Rings.
Leo Burnett argued that the sword-fighting scenes were cartoon-like and did
not feature any blood, injuries or realistic actions, and that the enemies were
all fictional monsters.
The agency added that the gun-fire in the ad did not show any bullets hitting
the target, but merely implied the action.
In throwing out the complaints, the ASA said that it believed viewers would
recognise that the ad was showcasing the range of computer games available on
the Wii and was intending to communicate that men, women, teenagers and children
would all enjoy using the console.
"We noted that the ad featured scenes from many different games, several of
which were family-oriented and involved, for example, playing golf, tennis and
baseball, fishing and bursting balloons," the ASA stated in its ruling.
"We considered that the scenes from Red Steel did not feature
explicit or graphic violence and were only one part of the ad, which primarily
promoted a games console aimed at people of all ages and running games in a
variety of genres.
"We also considered that viewers were unlikely to link the ad to recent
events in Iraq. We concluded that the ad was unlikely to cause serious or
widespread offence."
Do you agree?
Have your say on this article