Red Hat is dismissing
Oracle's new support programme for
the Red Hat Enterprise Linux application as a fork that will void certification
and compatibility.
"This derivate will not be Red hat Enterprise Linux and customers will not
have the assurance of compatibility with the Red hat Enterprise Linux ecosystem,
" Red Hat wrote on its website.
Oracle on Wednesday unveiled a support
programme for Red Hat's Linux distribution, undercutting Red Hat's support fees
by as much as 60 per cent.
The database vendor also will offer indemnification and support for older
software versions. Neither option is currently available from Red Hat, Oracle
chief executive Larry Ellison charged in a keynote on Wednesday.
Oracle will develop its own patches and requires users to change their update
server from to an Oracle URL.
Charging that its Linux distribution is "unfakeble" Red Hat on its
website warned that the
Oracle updates will amount to changes to the code. Because these aren't
certified by Red Hat, they may cause unexpected behaviour, invalidating Red
Hat's hardware and software validations.
Red Hat also challenged the notion that it doesn't support older versions of
its operating system. Red Hat subscribers instead receive updates for versions
that are up to 7 years old and if needed can get hot-fixes.
Raven Zachary, a senior analyst covering open source for the
451 Group, said that the fork discussion is
mainly a matter of perception, but added that it is in Oracle's best interest to
maintain compatibility.
Although Oracle has made its new support available to anybody and isn't
limiting itself to current Oracle users, the new support offering will mostly
appeal to current Oracle clients, said Zachary.
"If you're not an existing Oracle customer, I see only a cost advantage in
talking to Oracle. But look at the disruption of changing installations. The
cost saving isn't going to help much there," Zachary told
vnunet.com.
Although Oracle advertises that switching support providers is as easy as
changing the URL of the update server, Zachary warned that enterprises will
still need to go through a full assessment.
"I don't know of a single enterprise that would change a technology without
going through a full quality assurance cycle," he said.
Oracle's support is not all bad news for Red Hat. The offering validates Red
Hat's Linux lead.
"Even though there has been a lot of focus on competition, it is solidifying
Red Hat Enterprise Linux as the standard distribution," said Zachary.
Do you agree?
Have your say on this article