Google has issued a
stinging rebuke to the US government's legal request for
copies of all search terms used, and the URLs they identify, over a two-month
period.
The US Department of
Justice filed a legal case against the search firm last
month after it refused to hand over the data, which the government is
seeking to help devise a law that would protect children from internet
pornography.
Google's
legal
response describes the government's request as "so uninformed as to be
nonsensical".
"The very fact that the government is so uninformed about the value of search
and URL information, and so dismissive of Google's interest in protecting it,
speaks volumes about why the court should protect Google from this compelled
disclosure," stated the brief filed by lawyers at legal firm
Perkins Coie.
"The government's cavalier attitude undermines any credibility in the
assertion it later makes that it can or will protect Google against loss or
further disclosure of the information, a promise that is hollow in the context
of litigation in any event."
Google received a subpoena for the data from the Department of Justice on 25
August 2005 and has been fighting the case ever since.
MSN and
Yahoo have handed over the
information but Ask
Jeeves, the fourth most popular search site in the US, has not been asked.
Google is fighting the case on three fronts, insisting that the information
is useless for the proposed task; that disclosure would reveal trade secrets and
lead to loss of business; and that the order would place an undue burden on the
company.
Do you agree?
Have your say on this article