The first UK study into the health effects of mobile phones has given them a
tentative all clear.
A team of researchers from the
Institute of Cancer Research
and the universities of
Leeds,
Nottingham and
Manchester found no
link between phone use and the growth of
glioma, the
most common type of brain tumour.
But the researchers admitted that where tumours did occur they were on the
side of the head most used to make calls.
"This finding may be due to people with glioma brain tumours linking mobile
phone use to the side of the tumour and therefore over reporting the use of a
phone on the same side as their tumour," said Patricia McKinney, professor of
paediatric epidemiology at
Leeds
Institute of Genetics, Health and Therapeutics. "This results in under
reporting use on the opposite side of the head."
However since mobile phones have only been in widespread use since the
mid-1990s the report noted that the study had limited data to research. The
survey covered 966 people with glioma tumours and a control group of 1,716
volunteers without the tumours.
There had been concern that longer term users who would have had analogue
phones in the mid-1980s might be more at risk due to the increased power used at
the time.
But being an early adopter of mobile phones has been given a health OK after
the study showed no rise in tumours.
However electromagnetic safety pressure group
Powerwatch has
rejected the findings, insisting that they ignore those who die early from fast
growing tumours.
"It our view that this is a highly misleading claim, either through a
deliberate and politically motivated attempt to spin the information towards a
set goal, or due to incompetent assessment of the results in the report," said
director Alasdair Philips.
"As it is, it presents a highly misleading overall picture and may make it
harder to get funding to look into causes of high grade gliomas, about which
there is still little known.
"We can only hope that the conclusions are down to an incompetent
misrepresentation as opposed to a more sinister motivation."
Do you agree?
Have your say on this article