Scientologists use DMCA against Google

Just fighting terrorism, the church says

Ben Tudor

The Church of Scientology has forced Google to remove sites from its search engine using the controversial US Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA).

Lawyers representing the group, created by former science fiction writer L Ron Hubbard, used the DMCA to force Google to remove links to copyrighted material and has compared its actions to fighting terrorism.

Advertisement

In a statement, the Church said: "Copyright protection is one of the oldest rights afforded in [the US]. It is enshrined in the US constitution."

Google complied and removed references to xenu.net, a high profile anti-Scientology website, and Operation Clambake, the name of the site's campaign.

The site was ranked first in any Google search for the word 'Scientology'. Google listed 128 pages served by xenu.net, including www.xenu.net itself.

A Google spokesman stated: "Certain pages of the xenu.net website were removed from our search engine earlier this week in response to a copyright infringement notification under the DMCA."

The company would not comment further on the events surrounding the case.

According to xenu.net's webmaster, Norwegian resident Andreas Heidal-Lund, Google only notified him of the delisting after he repeatedly asked to know why his link had been removed from the site.

Heidel-Lund explained: "I can't respond to this complaint [in the US courts], because there is a clause in the DMCA that says I have to submit to US jurisdiction in order to do so.

"The people at Google are not bad people, they have just been forced into doing this by the DMCA.

"If this case becomes a precedent, it could mean a lot of work for Google. There is no precedent in the US at the moment for search engines linking to material that others want removed under the DMCA.

"It is in Google's best interests to make sure that this does not become common practice."

Under the Act, copyright owners can force sites to remove copyrighted material. The legislation has been roundly criticised by civil rights groups in the US.

But the Church of Scientology defended its actions, maintaining that it took the steps to prevent attacks on its members. The statement read: "To attempt to make this into a 'free speech' issue is a red herring and, in effect, advocates lawlessness on the internet.

"Hate speech and other extremist propaganda on the internet has provenly [sic] driven unstable individuals to commit felonious acts against church members and church property."

Among other criteria, Google ranks sites depending on how many other sites link to it.

Xenu.net's rankings have been boosted massively in recent weeks through a practice known as 'Google bombing' where weblog editors link to the site they want to boost in the ratings using a key word.

In the case of xenu.net, the word used in the link was 'Scientology'.

Google later reinstated xenu.net in its rankings. The front page of the website does not contain information that is copyrighted by the Church of Scientology.

  • Have your say
  • Send to a friend
  • Print
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • Share

Tags:

Do you agree?

Further reading

HP threatens Tru64 hole publisher

SnoSoft faces DMCA breach

Cult search engine 'bigger than Google'

Norwegian firm claims 2.1 billion web pages

Google tests distributed computing

Users can help cure cancer or save the world

Google bombing: the next web game

The successor to Googlewhack is here

Related whitepapers

Related jobs

Most watched

eu flag

V3.co.uk weekly debrief, 6 Nov 09

This week, Europe decides what to do with illegal file sharers

Intel unveils its micro server platform

Small-enclosure systems take aim at hosting market

IT white papers

Search white papers

Top categories

Poll

Impact of Information Overload poll

Impact of Information Overload poll

What is the biggest problem your firm faces as a result of the data explosion?

View poll results

Advertisement

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Enter email address to edit your newsletter preferences

Job of the week

Search thousands of IT jobs :

Search thousands of IT jobs:

Advanced search

Hiring now on ComputingCareers:

Related IT jobs

Search thousands of IT jobs :

Search thousands of IT jobs:

Advanced search

Spotlight

eu flag

V3.co.uk weekly debrief, 6 Nov 09

This week, Europe decides what to do with illegal file...

Dell Adamo XPS

Dell launches ultra-thin Adamo XPS

World's thinnest laptop will be available by Christmas

Top 10 articles, 6 November 2009

The worst Microsoft products of all time, and a USB...

Iain Thomson

Pirate Bay shutdown could be inspiring online militancy

Recent Swedish attacks raise worrying possibility

Primary Navigation