Apple iPhone 3G
Apple has declined to join an initiative to standardise mobile phone chargers

Comment: Apple fights against the standard charger mob

Apple's unique approach to device charging has frustrations for iPhone and iPod users, says Madeline Bennett

Madeline Bennett

The decision by the mobile industry to sign up for standard phone chargers is great news for the environment, as it will cut down on electronics manufacturing and waste. And it's great for mobile users as it will cut down on the number of unwanted, old phone chargers clogging up their drawers throughout the house and office. (Watch this video to see how I feel about all the various chargers I've got - this guy feels about cables as I do about mobile phone chargers).

The announcement was made earlier this week at the Mobile World Congress show in Barcelona, and it's long overdue from my point of view.

Advertisement

The GSM Association revealed that 17 leading operators and manufacturers - including Motorola, Nokia and Sony Ericsson - signed up last Friday to a proposal to use a standard micro-USB charging unit. The two noticeable absences were handset maker HTC and Apple.

So while as of 1 January 2012, you'll be able to switch from a Nokia to a Motorola phone without requiring a new charging unit as part of that purchase, anyone splashing out on a new iPhone or HTC device from that point will find that their chargers aren't compatible with those from other vendors.

I wasn't surprised to hear that Apple is one of the only handset makers that hasn't signed up to the agreement, having experienced first-hand Apple's approach to compatibility at the weekend.

I'm a big iPod fan, and am now on about my fourth or fifth model. I've recently switched from using one of the original nanos to the new curved design, and have been impressed so far with the latest version. That was until I tried using it in one of the many iPod speaker docks I've got dotted around the house.

Turns out Apple has updated the connector on the new iPod nano so it doesn't support FireWire charging anymore - but this also means my new iPod doesn't work properly with any of the different iPod docks I've already got, as they're all FireWire-based.

The JBL Radial model I've got works OK, as in I can hear music out of it. However, whereas my old iPod would be charging up while it was sitting in the dock, whether in use or switched off, the new version just comes up with the message: 'Charging is not supported with this device'.

I tried using another set of speakers by Logic3 to see if they could charge up my new iPod, but they didn't work either and I got the same message. So halfway through cooking dinner, I had to run upstairs and dig through my cupboards and drawers to try and find a separate iPod charging unit, and then put the iPod on charge for a bit, and then switch it back into the docks to hear a bit more music.

And that was on top of the fact that, with the Logic3 speakers, the iPod kept losing its connection while sitting in the dock and the song kept cutting out - leading to me going backwards and forwards between the oven and speakers laden down with hot pans to shove the iPod firmly back into the slot. Not exactly a seamless audio experience.

So I've either got to find new iPod speakers that don't charge using FireWire, and splash out on them instead, or carry on using the existing lot but always make sure I've got my separate charger with me and be ready to shove the iPod back into place in the dock when the connection goes and the music cuts out.

Come on Apple, can it really be that difficult to pick a standard and stick to it, or to just go with the rest of the industry?

  • Have your say
  • Send to a friend
  • Print
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • Share

Do you agree?

Further reading

Apple iPhone 3G

Rival touch-screen devices failing to live up to iPhone

Only Apple iPhone 3G and LG Renoir touch-screens make the mobile phone top 10

Mobile World Congress 2009

Mobile industry agrees on standard charger

Energy efficient micro-USB chargers to become the norm

Apple and Microsoft face new legal actions

Apple involved in patent dispute while Microsoft accused of profiting from Vista unpopularity

Apple iPhone changes on the way?

Temporary chief executive Tim Cook hints at changes to business model

Related whitepapers

Related jobs

Most watched

iPhone

Video Review: iPhone 3GS

We put Apple's latest iPhone through its paces

V3.co.uk weekly debrief, 5 Feb 2010

This week we cover the continuing controversy surrounding the Orange T-Mobile deal

Analysis and Reports

Using managed services to protect mobile data users from the latest security threats

Counting the cost of data security: the benefits of secured mobile services

Shifting Disaster Recovery targets with SharePoint and SQL server configurations

Using a hostbased recovery system for mission-critical systems

Poll

Adobe Flash poll

Adobe Flash poll

Do you agree with Steve Jobs about Flash being buggy?

View poll results

Advertisement

White paper library

Keep up to date with the latest products, services and technologies from the world's leading IT companies; IThound.com brings you over 6,000 white papers, case studies and analyst reports.

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Enter email address to edit your newsletter preferences

Job of the week

Search thousands of IT jobs :

Search thousands of IT jobs:

Advanced search

Hiring now on ComputingCareers:

Related IT jobs

Search thousands of IT jobs :

Search thousands of IT jobs:

Advanced search

Advertisement

Spotlight

Neil Sanderson

Interview: Microsoft UK virtualisation chief Neil Sanderson

Sanderson outlines Microsoft's plans for Hyper-V, cloud computing and virtual...

Google

Google moves into social networking with Buzz

Facebook gets opposition in consumer and enterprise spheres

Nvidia

Nvidia pitches Optimus as prime notebook platform

New system pairs onboard and discrete chips

OpenDNSSEC

OpenDNSSEC service goes live

New security project encrypts Domain Name System traffic

Primary Navigation