The UK government has made a U-turn in its efforts to clamp down on piracy,
announcing today that it will consider cutting off illegal downloaders from the
internet.
If the proposals are enforced, the UK will be the first country in Europe to
restrict citizens' access to the internet. Some citizen rights groups have
criticised the move, arguing that internet access should be considered a
fundamental human right.
In May, similar proposals were driven forward in France by president Nicolas
Sarkozy under a 'three-strikes' policy, whereby file sharers would be kicked off
the internet for up to a year after three offences.
But the country's highest authority, the Constitutional Council,
ruled
against the plans, insisting that internet freedom is essential to a modern
democracy.
The UK government has said that suspending the internet accounts of
file-sharers is still a matter for public consultation, but commentators
maintain that the policy being up for consideration is a significant step change
in efforts to curb illegal downloading.
The
Digital
Britain report outlined an agenda to reduce illegal downloads by 80 per cent
over the next two years by giving new powers to Ofcom.
Under the report's proposals opened up for public consultation on 24 June,
Ofcom will work with internet service providers (ISPs) to target individuals
sharing files with peers, and send them written warnings. If a warning does not
work, the identity of the downloader will be given to the copyright holder which
will then be able to take legal action.
A new report from the Department of Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS),
has added new measures to the consultation, although these will take effect only
if the softer measures scheduled to be introduced next spring fail to work,
according to a BIS spokeswoman.
She explained that the proposals are different from the three-strikes plans
put forward by the French, even though they are similar in that two warning
letters will be sent before an individual is cut off from their ISP.
"The difference is that illegal downloading is a civil offence in the UK and
a criminal offence in France," the spokeswoman said, although she could not
explain how the difference in definition would affect an individual accused of
piracy.
She added that, if the measures are introduced, it would be in early 2011.
Do you agree?
Have your say on this article