A leading Tory MP has launched a stinging attack on Downing Street's
Transformational
Government strategy for delivering public services, labelling it "sinister"
and "an end to privacy" for all citizens.
Shadow immigration minister
Damian
Green outlined the three main aims of the initiative during a speech to
right-wing think tank the
Centre
for Policy Studies yesterday. The strategy was originally launched by Tony
Blair in 2005.
Green described the promise of IT services designed around the citizen and
business as "largely cosmetic", and referred to the idea of broadening and
deepening the government's IT and professionalism as "largely comic".
The member for Ashford also condemned the third aim of promoting a "culture
of shared services to release efficiencies" as "highly sinister".
"It has its roots in a false analogy with the private sector, which has
indeed used ICT to provide services more efficiently and cheaply," said Green.
"The difference, of course, is that in almost all industries any private
sector operator cannot compel us to use its services. Government can not only
compel us to use them, but can change the rules, and the terms and conditions,
whenever it suits."
Green believes that this has led to an increasingly large number of
government databases and soaring costs.
"Even the government cannot provide an accurate figure for the cost of its
Transformational Government programme," he added. "Yet only about 30 per cent of
government IT projects succeed."
The attack comes just a day after Green's colleague, shadow home secretary
Chris Grayling,
criticised
the government's DNA database, saying that the Brown administration had been
dragging its feet over implementing changes to comply with European Union law.
Do you agree?
Have your say on this article