This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.  > Find out more here

 

All the latest UK technology news, reviews and analysis

Apple iPad vs Microsoft Surface RT vs Google Nexus 10 head to head review

by Alastair Stevenson

04 Dec 2012

View Comments

  • Tweet this
Apple iPad vs Microsoft Surface RT vs Google Nexus 10 three-quarter view

Performance
When it comes to performance all three of the tablets are very good, with the Nexus, iPad and Surface all using top end components.

However, of the three the iPad is the most interesting, packing Apple's A6X dual-core processor with quad-core graphics. Apple's yet to reveal the processor's exact speed, though traditionally iPad components have clocked in at lower than competing Android devices.

Yet, this doesn't mean the iPad is necessarily slower than the Nexus 10 or Surface RT. In the past despite being on paper slower than competitors, the iPads have managed to offer equivalent or superior performance thanks to their iOS software.

Apple has always used a closed development process when creating its products. The advantage of this is that it lets Apple optimise its software and components to work together, thus meaning they can theoretically match the performance of on paper faster products.

This meant that running against the 1.7GHz Cortex A15-powered Nexus 10, we found Apple's iPad generally offered equivalent to slightly better performance.

The same was true when we tested the iPad against the 1.3GHz quad-core Nvidia Tegra 3 T30-powered Surface RT. Here again we found the iPad boasted slightly quicker performance, generally loading videos and launching apps a fraction of a second faster.

That said, this is all based on very basic speed testing. To date there isn't a benchmarking tool that reliably works on all three platforms, making it difficult to fully judge the three tablets' comparative performance.

Winner: The Apple iPad

Camera
When it comes to taking photos and shooting video the Microsoft Surface is the worst performer, featuring bare-bones 720p front and rear cameras. Both cameras are pretty dire at taking photos, with images coming out hazier and with poorer colour balance than on the iPad and Nexus.

The reality is that both the Surface RT's cameras aren't really good for anything but video calling.Microsoft Surface RT test shot

Taken on the Microsoft Surface RT

The iPad and Nexus 10 however are slightly better, both featuring 5MP rear-facing cameras. Testing the two, neither tablet's cameras match the stellar performance seen on smartphones like the Lumia 920 or iPhone 5.iPad test shot

Taken on the Apple iPad 

Images taken in normal lighting conditions generally come out fine on both devices, boasting decent enough colour balance levels and being reasonably crisp. However, in more difficult high or low light conditions both are close to useless, with photos coming out hazy and unevenly coloured.Google Nexus 10 test shot

Taken on the Nexus 10

This means that while, if desperate the iPad and Nexus 10 can be used as cameras, we wouldn't recommend it. Luckily the Nexus 10's 1.9MP and iPad's 1.2MP front-facing cameras are more than adequate for video calling purposes.

Winner: Tie between Google Nexus 10 and Apple iPad

Next: Connectivity, storage, battery and price

Do you agree

blog comments powered by Disqus

Popular Threads

Powered by Disqus
BlackBerry Q5

BlackBerry Q5 video demo

BlackBerry's latest smartphone is a mid-tier handset that will cost less than the Q10 and Z10

Updating your subscription status Loading

Connect with V3.co.uk

Sign up to our daily or weekly newsletters

newsletter sign-up button

mcafee

7 requirements for hybrid web delivery

It's no longer one or other with web security; you can now have a virtualisation and SaaS hybrid model

navisite

BYOD: the implications for the IT team

BYOD is important for employee satisfaction, but poses challenges in terms of security, productivity loss and costs

Managed Services Sales / Account Manager

Growing IT Consultancy are currently looking for a Managed...

PHP / MySQL Developer - PHP, MySQL, Linux, Back End

PHP / MySQL Developer - PHP, MySQL, Linux, Back End...

eCommerce Business Analyst

eCommerce Business Analyst The Role Work with the...

Java Developer - 12 Month Contract - Southern Ireland

Java Developer - 12 Month Contract - Southern Ireland...

To send to more than one email address, simply separate each address with a comma.