This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. > Find out more here
by James Dohnert
08 Feb 2013
Motorola has had 13 claims in its patent infringement case against Microsoft dismissed by a US judge.
The patents in question deal with the encoding and decoding of video. For Motorola and Microsoft the case stems back to 2010 when the original patent infringement allegations were filed in a western district court of Washington State.
Microsoft had asked judge James Robart to dismiss the claims on Motorola patents 7310374, 7310375, 7310376. Microsoft alleged that the sloppy language in those patents meant Motorola's claims were invalid.
Judge Robart's has agreed with Microsoft's allegations. According to the judge's summary on the ruling, Motorola was unable to prove the patents in question's properly outline an infringement.
"The 'means for decoding' limitations claim[s] all corresponding structure under the sun by expansively defining the function in the specification as anything that decodes digital data," wrote judge Robart in his summary for the case.
"This definition renders the 'means for decoding' limitation invalid for indefiniteness."
The ruling adds to the lengthy Motorola v. Microsoft patent infringement case. Motorola brought the case to court in 2010.
Google-subsidiary Motorola Mobility had claimed that it deserves to be awarded as much as $4bn dollars for the use of its patents. Meanwhile, Microsoft argued the firm is only entitled to about $1m for the patents.
Prior to this ruling judge Robart shot down Motorola's attempts to get a sales ban on certain Microsoft devices that it alleges are infringing.
Latest stories from Law
Related articles
Related jobs
Poll
Which productivity tools do you use for work?
BlackBerry's latest smartphone is a mid-tier handset that will cost less than the Q10 and Z10
Updating your subscription status
Connect with V3.co.uk
It's no longer one or other with web security; you can now have a virtualisation and SaaS hybrid model
BYOD is important for employee satisfaction, but poses challenges in terms of security, productivity loss and costs
EXCLUSIVE ROLE! GLOBAL COMPANY! GREAT DEVELOPMENT OPPORTUNITIES...
Linux Systems Administrator (UNIX, Sys Admin) – Brighton...
GREAT CLIENT!SUPERB PROSPECTS!COMPETITIVE SALARY...
My client based in West Sussex are looking for a quality...
Keep up to date with the latest products, services and technologies from the world's leading IT companies. IThound.com brings you over 2,000 white papers, case studies and analyst reports.
Do you agree