This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.  > Find out more here

 

All the latest UK technology news, reviews and analysis

Apple wins another patent case against Motorola

by James Dohnert

19 Dec 2012

View Comments

  • Tweet this
An Apple logo

An International Trade Commission (ITC) Judge has ruled that Apple's iPhone does not infringe on a Motorola Mobility patent.

Judge Thomas Pender found that the patent in question, number 6246862, is invalid because of prior art found in an older patent. Motorola's patent covers technology used to prevent accidental touchscreen input. The case still has to go in front of an ITC commission for final review.

According to Judge Pender, Motorola's patent is invalid due to prior art found in patent number 6052464. The judge ruled that the prior art showed that the patent at the heart of the case was an obvious evolution of existing technology.

Patent number 624682 covers technology which prevents accidental touchscreen input through the use of a close-proximity sensor. The patent was originally assigned to Motorola in 1989.

Judge Pender originally ruled that Apple was not guilty of infringement in the case because Motorola's use of the term "close-proximity sensor" was too broad for an infringement determination.

Following that ruling, an ITC commission asked Pender to re-review the case on behalf of Motorola. The commission will now review Judge Pender's latest ruling for a final determination.

This isn't the only case between Apple and Motorola to receive a ruling recently. A Wisconsin judge dismissed a case between Apple and Motorola in November.

Judge Barbara Crabb dismissed the case under the belief that Apple would not have followed the courts guidance if a pro-Motorola verdict was given.

Both Apple and Motorola were unavailable for comment at the time of this posting.

Do you agree

blog comments powered by Disqus

Poll

Business security poll

How concerned are you by the rising tide of cyber threats?

16%

56%

10%

9%

9%

Popular Threads

Powered by Disqus
Sony Xperia Z vs Apple iPhone 5

Sony Xperia Z vs Apple iPhone 5 head to head video review

V3 pits Sony's rugged flagship against Apple's premier handset

Updating your subscription status Loading

Connect with V3.co.uk

Sign up to our daily or weekly newsletters

newsletter sign-up button

mcafee

7 requirements for hybrid web delivery

It's no longer one or other with web security; you can now have a virtualisation and SaaS hybrid model

navisite

BYOD: the implications for the IT team

BYOD is important for employee satisfaction, but poses challenges in terms of security, productivity loss and costs

Network and Security Solutions Engineer

Network and Security Solutions Engineer Location: Caerphilly...

Lead Customer Support Engineer - world class tech start-up - London

Lead Customer Support Engineer - Mobile Applications...

Application Packaging Specialist - London

Software Systems Specialist - London The job holder...

Senior Software Engineer - World class Tech startup - London

Senior Software Engineer – Cloud platform (enterprise...

Keep up to date with the latest products, services and technologies from the world's leading IT companies. IThound.com brings you over 2,000 white papers, case studies and analyst reports.

To send to more than one email address, simply separate each address with a comma.