All the latest UK technology news, reviews and analysis

Judge orders patents from HTC and Apple agreement opened

05 Dec 2012
Court room

US district Judge Lucy Koh has ordered Apple and HTC to disclose certain details involved in their recent patent licensing deal.

The decision comes as part of the ongoing patent case between Apple and Samsung. Samsung had argued that the patents in the agreement were relevant to the case.

Apple and HTC had been fighting the argument hoping to get the entirety of the deal sealed by the courts.

Judge Koh's decision means that the patents in question will be released to the public. However, it will not extend to patent pricing and royalty terms. Judge Koh wrote in her motion that releasing pricing and royalty terms could hurt the companies ability to negotiate future patent licensing deals.

"There are compelling reasons to seal pricing and royalty terms, as they may place the parties to the agreement at a disadvantage in future negotiations, but there is nothing in the remainder of the agreement that presents a sufficient risk of competitive harm to justify keeping it from the public." Judge Koh wrote.

"Accordingly, Samsung's motion to seal is granted with regard to the pricing and royalty terms of the agreement only, and denied with regard to the rest of the agreement."

While the some details of the patent agreement will not be allowed for use in court, Samsung has won the right to use the patent deal, in its entirety, for the case.

This case has long been gestating in court. Apple aims to get a sales ban on certain Samsung products it believes infringe its patents.

According to legal analyst Pamela Jones, if the patents in the HTC agreement are the same as those in the Samsung trial, Apple's chances of obtaining a sales ban recede.

Jones wrote on her Groklaw blog that Samsung may be able to use the HTC agreement to prove that Apple doesn't need an injunction.

"If the patents on the list are the same patents as in this case, it will make it much easier for Samsung to avoid an injunction. As you just saw in the Microsoft vs Motorola case in Seattle, if money can make you whole, you normally can't get an injunction," wrote Jones.

"And if they aren't, there is a Samsung argument that customers don't care about those features enough to pay for them, which could impact the damages figure."

HTC declined to comment on the news. Apple was unavailable for comment at the time of this posting. 

The next round of the case between Apple and Samsung is expected to head to court on 6 December.

  • Comment  
  • Tweet  
  • Google plus  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Stumble Upon  
James Dohnert

James is a freelance writer and editor. In addition to ClickZ, his work has appeared in publications like V3, The Commonwealth Club,, and Shonen Jump magazine. He studied Journalism at Weber State University.

More on Government
What do you think?
blog comments powered by Disqus

BYOD vs CYOD vs BYOC poll

Which approach is your firm taking to managing employees' mobile devices?

Popular Threads

Powered by Disqus
Sony Xperia Z2 smartphone running Android KitKat 4.4

Sony Xperia Z2 video

We test out the latest Android KitKat flagship from Sony

Updating your subscription status Loading

Get the latest news (daily or weekly) direct to your inbox with V3 newsletters.

newsletter sign-up button

Data protection: the key challenges

Deduplication is a foundational technology for efficient backup and recovery


iPad makes its mark in the enterprise

The iPad can become a supercharged unified communications endpoint, allowing users to enhance their productivity

Java Developers X2 - Oslo

Java, Algorithms, Data Structures, Groovy, Rails, Linux...

Front End Web Developers x2 - Oslo

HTML, CSS (SASS), JavaScript, JQuery, Angular JS, ROR...

Web Developers x3 - work from home

HTML, CSS, JavaScript, PHP/PHP 5, MySQL, LAMP, Subversion...

Front End Web Developers (eCommerce) x3

HTML, CSS, JavaScript, eCommerce Package (Ideally Demandware...
To send to more than one email address, simply separate each address with a comma.