This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. > Find out more here
by Dan Worth
09 Dec 2011
Apple could be banned from selling a range its products in Germany, including the iPhone 4S and the iPad 2, after Motorola won an injunction.
The case relates to wireless technology patents owned by Motorola and the decision to grant an injunction is a huge setback for Apple, who until now have had the upper hand in several ongoing legal disputes with technology rivals.
Motorola had already achieved a default judgment while Apple readied its appeal for that decision but the Karlsruhe Higher Regional Court again ruled in favour of Motorola in a hearing on Friday.
Apple confirmed it would appeal the ruling and told its customers in Germany that it was confident its products would remain on sale.
"We're going to appeal the court's ruling right away. Holiday shoppers in Germany should have no problem finding the iPad or iPhone they want," it said.
Motorola's general counsel Scott Offer welcomed the ruling as proof Motorola was right to take action against Apple in the courts.
"Today's decision validates Motorola's efforts to enforce its patents against Apple's infringement," he said.
"We have been negotiating with Apple and offering them reasonable licensing terms and conditions since 2007, and will continue our efforts to resolve our global patent dispute as soon as practicable."
Patent analyst Florian Mueller told V3 that Apple can no longer sell products that fall foul of the relevant patent unless it modifies the devices in question, which could prove unworkable.
"Apple is banned from selling all devices that infringe the patent-in-suit. If they dropped the patented functionality, they'd be fine, but it's unclear whether that's a viable option," he said.
He added that Apple would definitely appeal the ruling to try to hold up the injunction for the duration of the appeals proceedings.
If Apple fails to get the injunction suspended, Motorola will be able to enforce the ban on the products being sold in the country, but at the risk of severe financial loss further down the line due to the inclusion of a bond of €100m in the ruling, Mueller said.
"This is the amount Motorola might have to pay Apple if the injunction is later overturned by an appellate [appeals] court. If you enforce an improperly-granted injunction while it's being appealed, you're liable later if you lose," Mueller told V3.
The original bond request by Apple was a whopping €2bn but the judge lowered this to €100m.
The decision is a huge twist in the ongoing legal battles taking place between major smartphone and tablet vendors, which have seen Apple and Samsung in particular taking each other on in courts across the world.
Latest stories from Mobile Software
Related videos
Related articles
Related jobs
Poll
How concerned are you by the rising tide of cyber threats?
BlackBerry's latest smartphone is a mid-tier handset that will cost less than the Q10 and Z10
Updating your subscription status
Connect with V3.co.uk
It's no longer one or other with web security; you can now have a virtualisation and SaaS hybrid model
BYOD is important for employee satisfaction, but poses challenges in terms of security, productivity loss and costs
PHP Developer £30,000 - £35,000 We are looking for...
Corporate Treasurer - Banking London - £70k-£120k...
Product Manager – Insurance (Telematics) £40k-£50k...
Product Manager £40k-£50k+Bens + Relocation Package...
Keep up to date with the latest products, services and technologies from the world's leading IT companies. IThound.com brings you over 2,000 white papers, case studies and analyst reports.
Do you agree