10 Oct 2007
A Scottish branch of car repair shop Kwik Fit has been taken to court by the Performing Rights Society (PRS) for not paying royalties after staff listened to the radio at work.
Lord Emslie, the judge at the Court of Session in Edinburgh, has allowed the case to go ahead, and the PRS is asking for damages of £200,000.
The organisation claims that staff should pay royalties because they take radios into work where other people can hear them.
"If copyright music is being played in public - in shops, restaurants, workplaces or any other business - clearance is needed to do so from the owners of that music," said the PRS in a statement.
"Some 92 per cent of PRS members earn less than £10,000 a year from PRS royalties so the income from unlicensed use is important to them.
"Kwik Fit has been given every opportunity to take out the appropriate licences but has refused. Court action is regrettable but Kwik Fit's actions have left us with no choice."
The PRS filed over 200 complaints that radios were being played audibly. But Kwik Fit responded by saying that it did not allow radios to be used at work.
Lord Emslie said in his ruling: "The key point to note, it was said, was that the findings on each occasion were the same with music audibly 'blaring' from employees' radios in such circumstances that [Kwik Fit's] local and central management could not have failed to be aware of what was going on.
"The allegations are of a widespread and consistent picture emerging over many years whereby routine copyright infringement in the workplace was, or inferentially must have been, known to and 'authorised' or 'permitted' by local and central management."
Latest stories from Communications
Related articles
Related jobs
Poll
Are you confident that the UK's IT infrastructure is secure from attack in the wake of the Flame malware revelations?
Orange and Intel talk us through the ins and outs of their San Diego smartphone
Connect with V3.co.uk
Social networking is almost ubiquitous. This white paper examines the benefits and risks and it looks at the different ways companies can reconcile them
The importance of understanding your infrastructure
My London client is looking for an experienced Programme...
My leading client is looking for a number of excellent...
My client, a leading international name in Manufacturing...
My client is looking for an Automated Engineer/Developer...
Keep up to date with the latest products, services and technologies from the world's leading IT companies. IThound.com brings you over 2,000 white papers, case studies and analyst reports.
Do you agree?
hello!!!
my name is terry i would like to say that i feel that your arguement is pathetic. thank you
Posted by: terry goran erickson 06 Oct 2009
PRS Gestapo
What is the country coming to? when law abiding workers can`t turn on their radios while people in prison can ! Don`t idiots who make up these rules realise that production increases with the benefit of background music? Will the very last person to leave the country please turn off that bloddy radio !!
Posted by: Joe bloggs 12 Jun 2009
Thank God for peace and quiet
I don`t object to people playing music at work . But every where you go it`s cranked up to the limit. I can`t under stand people who can`t seem to work without a radio. There is some hypocrisy here, I am pretty sure that if they had the talent to pen a popular tune there hand would be out to take the income that it would produce.
Posted by: Wm Buchanan 24 May 2009
Royalty Free Music Radio
Well why not use www.rfmradio.co.uk its a radio station playing royalty free music here in the UK CDs are available for businesses without internet access. See website for more details
Posted by: Colin 10 Apr 2009
ANOTHER BRITISH TAX RIP OFF!!!
When I produce something at work I then sell it....ONCE. I don't continually get paid for it over and over again for years to come. Most successful entertainers are far richer than I'll ever be. Licence to listen to a radio!.......Shove it where the sun don't shine! (Hey, that could be a song title..lol)
Posted by: Kev 10 Oct 2008
Joke
like someone said before work would be boring with no radio its alright for the people who sit at at home all day also in work you hear stuff then buy it only for hearing music at work you wouldnt know whats out pillocks
Posted by: ian 10 Jun 2008
Anti PRS website
For anyone interested we have set up a campaign website, see www.saynotoprs.com Regards Bob
Posted by: Bob Bruce 17 Jan 2008
Workplace radio
There is now a petition on the No.10 website aking for an exemption for radios played in the workplace from copyright infringement. Please add your signature and get Family, Friends and workmates to do the same. http://petitions.pm.gov.uk/WorkplaceRadio/ Thank You
Posted by: Steve Webb 14 Dec 2007
work place dull as it is "no radio"!! what next!!
yes i work for a tyre company in the midlands we have been told to switch off our radio's ,now for the past 6 weeks it has had an atmosphere so dull and quiet you just want to stay home in bed and not bother,work is an everyday life for most people we pay too much tax and too many taxes on every day living we are not robots! but this country is on a downward slope and no one will have a choice to get on and try and make something of what life they have left ,yes i do agree with one comment "too higher paid leaders with to much time on their hands"get it sorted before there be nothing for future generations ,the radio stations won't thank you and neither will the entertainments industry ,all the best kwikfit !!
Posted by: m.a.d for l.t.c 07 Nov 2007
Biting the hand that feeds them......
This is one way of the music industry cutting thier own throat's, Business premises, such as garages and factory's wont be willing to pay a licence they'll just tell employees to turn off all radio's, listening figures will go down as a result of which radio stations will lose advertising because noones listening to the radio. Are they going to Police the roads for people playing music too loud out of thier cars? or how about banning all these mobile phones that play music way to loud for personal use! OR is this just a case of someone with too much time on his/her hands trying to justify why they have a job?
Posted by: Robert Smith 02 Nov 2007
Is this legal?
We hav been approached about Playing radios in our warehouse by PRS. does anyone know the law on this matter?
Posted by: PJ 26 Oct 2007
PRS sues Kwik Fit for playing the radio
The PRS is looking very stupid right now...
Posted by: Simon 12 Oct 2007
what?
you've got to be kidding?
Posted by: deborah stalker 10 Oct 2007