13 Nov 2009
The Home Affairs Select Committee has urged home secretary Alan Johnson to reconsider plans to allow hacker Gary McKinnon to be extradited to the US to stand trial.
McKinnon is something of a cause célèbre and has gathered support from a wide range of factions, although what extra impact the intervention of this group will have is yet to be seen, especially since repeated attempts to stop the extradition have been rebuffed.
Committee chairman Keith Vaz has written to Johnson saying the extradition should be blocked on humanitarian grounds. In his letter Vaz writes: “Because of Mr McKinnon's precarious state of mental health, the Committee is of the view that he should not be extradited to the USA and that you should exercise your discretion in this case.”
However, Johnson is unlikely to be moved. Earlier this week he said the decision to extradite, and the rules surrounding the practice, were fair.
This morning, a poster on the Free Gary campaign blog wrote, "Why is it so hard for this Labour government to admit that they are wrong?"
The blog's mission statement reads: "It seems only just that Gary should face any charges in a British court, and to serve any sentence, if he is found guilty, in a British prison."
McKinnon is accused of "the biggest military hack of all time", although he claims he was only looking for evidence of extra-terrestrials.
Latest stories from Security
Related articles
Related jobs
Poll
What will be the biggest change to corporate technology in the future?
TFL director of Games transport Mark Evers discusses how the public transport network is preparing for this summer's event
Connect with V3.co.uk
The wrong printers, for the wrong tasks on the wrong contracts
Who leads the BI pack and who should we be watching out for?
Customer Insight Analyst- SAS/ SQL/ SPSS Key Words...
Java Deveoper/Programmer/Software Engineer, Algo Trading...
C#, WPF, Silverlight, UI Development, Software Engineers...
Java, Scala, Python, Software Engineer, Architect, Developer...
Keep up to date with the latest products, services and technologies from the world's leading IT companies. IThound.com brings you over 2,000 white papers, case studies and analyst reports.
Do you agree?
Shrinking British Justice
Push the legal point MP's! it is your job, forget the expense fiasco and the coming election and get on with it, our country has been in limbo fdar too long. It is plain to see, but as usual some people can not see the wood for the trees, an offence has been committed in England and the fairest and correct way to deal with it for some officer of our law to call on the culprit completely without prejudice, and get him before an English Court right away, then the Americans can put their case forward if they have one.But in this instance the imediate right of way is ours. And while we still have this bit of edge, it is also time to consider the good in all things for once, do we have a genius here who could be useful to his country, if so should we not be making use of his talent, after a lawful magistrate of our own has passed official judgement of course.
Posted by: Harold Philbin 28 Nov 2009
MPs urge Johnson to show clemency in McKinnon case
I thought we didn't extradite to countries which carry out torture ??????? The Americans didn't like (quite understandably) what McKinnon did to them and they are hell bent on retribution. However, why should we be party to a one way extradition treaty .Who set this up , Blair ???? If he is extradited, will we be given any guarantees that he will not be subject to any of these rendition flights and that ghouls like Dick Cheney will not sanction his love of waterboarding treatment on McKinnon (as foolish as he was) Someone should perhaps remind the Americans that we are allies (as well as underdogs) and we do not want to to again hear of their Enhanced Interrogation Techniques. Say NO to our allies. Whats been done has been done. It should now be treated as a Security lesson
Posted by: John Hardy 20 Nov 2009