01 Nov 2008
With the economy worsening and layoffs hitting more and more tech firms, IT news can be a bit depressing these days.
One of the most tried-and-trusted methods for beating the blues has always been to curl up with a good movie or two and get whisked away into another world.
Unfortunately for those in the tech world, Hollywood's portrayal of geeks has always been spotty at best. The unrealistic and implausible depictions can set a tech-happy viewer off on an irritated, complaining rant faster than it takes the glasses-clad movie geek to 'hack the mainframe'.
So, if you do look to Hollywood to kick your recession blues this fall, here's a short list compiled by vnunet.com of movies for the easily-annoyed geek to steer clear of (or not, if you want a good laugh). If you want to add any of your own feel free to use the comments section below.
Johnny Mnemonic
Shaun Nichols: Great story in book form, awful movie. With all due respect to William Gibson, the continuation of Moore's ‘Law’ has made the line "I can store 320 gigabytes in my brain" a bit of a joke. (Gibson himself as much as admitted this; his latest novel has replaced brain-couriers with speedy iPod-toting teens.)
But that's not even the worst part. The fundamental underlying flaw which completely ruins the film version of Johnny Mnemomic for me is this: even in a futuristic high-tech ultra-capitalistic cyberpunk wasteland, who the hell is going to entrust any sort of important data to the brain of Keanu Reeves?
Iain Thomson: Couldn’t agree more on this one. There was some good use of technology, the passports spring to mind, but the way this film has dated has made it a stinker. And, as we’ll see below, Keanu Reeves is going to make regular appearances in this list.
Demolition Man
Shaun
Nichols: This early-90s Sly Stallone shoot 'em up portrays a high-tech future in
which a steady grid of ever-present consoles and kiosks ensure a squeaky-clean
society in which everyone is happy, friendly and polite. Sort of like a
Teletubby portrayal of Orwell's 1984.
The problem with this plot is that it assumes technology will make people more peaceful, polite and accommodating. Anyone who has ever spent more than five minutes on a message board, chat forum or YouTube knows that this is most definitely not the case.
Plus, I have little faith in any future in which Wesley Snipes has to dress like a five year-old.
Iain Thomson: You forgot that anyone who can hack a public internet terminal in seconds could bring out a lot more havoc than Snipes manages to. Add into that the apparent attraction of telepathic sex and it's thumbs down from me.
Latest stories from Communications
Related articles
Related jobs
Poll
What is the most important IT priority for your company this year?
Hands on with the highly anticipated Android 4.0 Ice Cream Sandwich hybrid tablet
Connect with V3.co.uk
This paper focuses on a series of best practices and techniques for development teams looking to improve their software development processes
Why good data management at all levels is essential in the modern business (video, 6mins)
A leading US Prop Trading House/Market Maker is currently...
A leading financial services group has an urgent requirement...
UI Developer Wanted - CSS, HTML, JavaScript with .NET...
Java Developer - Gloucestershire - £35-40k per annum...
Keep up to date with the latest products, services and technologies from the world's leading IT companies. IThound.com brings you over 2,000 white papers, case studies and analyst reports.
Do you agree?
Independence Day and Matrix
In defense of the binary code in ID, computer people work perfectly well with base-8 and hexadecimal, and they don't have to hack off or grow fingers to do it. I presume anyone who can build a starship will understand different number bases. And the physical basis of binary is it can be expressed as on/off, magnetized/unmagnetized, or any other pair of yes/no states. So binary is perfectly reasonable. Now believing the aliens don't have firewalls, and that a logo on our screens will look the same on their display devices, nope. But as someone once noted, the interoperability is explainable if they came to earth for the specific purpose of killing Bill Gates. On the Matrix, I had a WTF moment when they explained the battery thing, too. Why not use electric eels? And stretching a two-movie idea into three movies was a really bad idea. If they really wanted to make a third movie, do the prequel.
Posted by: Steve D 28 Mar 2009
One of my favorite thing about War Games
When they go to ask the two sysadmins for advice, the interplay between those two is amazingly well-done and reminiscent of many people I've encountered. What's really amazing is this is about the only time it's ever been portrayed in the movies or anywhere else.
Posted by: Fred 24 Mar 2009
War Games Criticism - Nonsense
The tech it used was accurate for the time - rather than this being bad for the 'under 28s' anyone with a brain cell will find it interesting and a rare sight of such equipment. The criticisms levied are moronic - by the same token a film about the Little Big Horn should see the 7th Cavalry equipped with Uzis - so much sexier than revolvers aren't they? If you're old enough to remember 8" floppy drives (I'm not) then be proud of it - not everyone under 28 is a brainless twat obsessed with 'yoof Kulture' and this month's Nikes!
Posted by: Gerard 08 Dec 2008
Further Jurassic Park
Not to mention, the point where the tween hacker girl got to the machines was after a total system reboot - she didn't fix anything, she just turned on the lights.
Posted by: Gonzobot 11 Nov 2008
.
Hiya. Just a quick correction re Jurassic Park. Michael Crichton sadly died on November 4th 2008.
Posted by: nige 10 Nov 2008
"Michael Crichton is living proof"
Rather unfortunate timing of this article me thinks.
Posted by: Damon 07 Nov 2008
Who could forget.........
Electric Dreams....eeeugh....enough said!!
Posted by: Joe Anka 07 Nov 2008
How Could You Overlook Terminal Error???
If you've ever seen the movie (Star Treks' Marina Sirtis is in it... but that doesnt help much), you'd be astounded at a virus' ability to go on the web and learn to talk, bring down airplanes, blow up power stations and electrocute cripples. Not bad eh? Watch it at your peril.....
Posted by: Alf Pomells 05 Nov 2008
Jurassic Park and Silicon Graphics
To be fair to Spielberg et al, anyone who spent time in a Chemistry Dept (or other sciences) in the early 90's would easily recognise the Silicon Graphics computer, complete with GUI. At the time, the prospect of opening a terminal and operating at CUI was only for the determined or Unix geeks. So, not altogether inaccurate in my view.
Posted by: alan wilson 03 Nov 2008
"Hello Dr. Falken, how about a nice game of chess?"
I love war games, probably Broderick's best film and he was only about 15. And yeah, all technology is going to date so you can't give it grief for that.
Posted by: aidan 03 Nov 2008