15 Oct 2010
Smartphones running Windows Phone 7 cannot connect to hidden Wi-Fi networks, V3.co.uk has discovered, meaning that consumers will have to broadcast their home network's presence if they want to connect a Windows handset.
Windows Phone 7, officially launched this week, is a modern smartphone platform that makes extensive use of online services. Consequently, handsets will make use of faster Wi-Fi connections wherever possible to speed data transfer.
But in early tests, V3.co.uk found that the only way to connect Windows Phone 7 to a Wi-Fi network is by choosing it from the list of those discovered when the handset scans for available networks.
This was confirmed by Oded Ran, Microsoft's head of consumer marketing for Windows Phone in the UK. "Windows Phone 7 at launch will not connect to hidden Wi-Fi networks," he said.
Wi-Fi networks are sometimes configured not to actively broadcast their network name, or SSID. Although this is considered ineffective as a security measure, hiding a network's SSID can prevent it being noticed by a casual observer, and the practice is believed to be quite common in business environments.
With Windows PCs and most other smartphone platforms, users can connect to a hidden network by manually supplying the network name and password, but this is not supported in Windows Phone 7.
"There is no ability to add networks manually. You need to choose the network you want to connect to, and if it is hidden you can't do that," explained Ran.
Microsoft's solution is simple: reveal your Wi-Fi network. Whether this is a big issue is debatable, as users should in any case be using encryption to secure their network, and hiding a Wi-Fi network is considered of dubious worth by many security experts.
"Clearly, those using [Windows phones] will have no option but to enable SSID broadcasting. In this case, other security measures become even more important, " said David Emm, senior security researcher at Kaspersky Lab.
On its own, hiding the SSID offers no kind of effective security measure, Emm explained. "But as a general rule, I'd recommend it as one of several steps, since broadcasting the SSID makes it more likely that your system may be targeted," he said.
However, the issue might become a problem if workers bring their new Windows phone to work and find that they cannot connect to the office Wi-Fi network.
IT departments may need to brace for a flood of support calls from irate employees if Windows Phone 7 handsets prove anywhere near as popular as Apple's iPhone.
Latest stories from Communications
Related videos
Related jobs
Poll
Are you confident that the UK's IT infrastructure is secure from attack in the wake of the Flame malware revelations?
V3 examines the key strengths and weaknesses of Samsung's latest iPhone killer
Connect with V3.co.uk
Social networking is almost ubiquitous. This white paper examines the benefits and risks and it looks at the different ways companies can reconcile them
The importance of understanding your infrastructure
About Us WorldPay provides a globally connected, locally...
About Us WorldPay provides a globally connected, locally...
SQL Server Developer - Our client, an international...
IT Technical Service Delivery Manager / ITIL / Reigate...
Keep up to date with the latest products, services and technologies from the world's leading IT companies. IThound.com brings you over 2,000 white papers, case studies and analyst reports.
Do you agree?
Hidden Wireless SSIDs Actually Leak Your SSID Name
"When you hide your wireless SSID [...], what actually happens behind the scenes is that your laptop or mobile device is going to start pinging over the air to try and find your router?no matter where you are. So you?re sitting there at the neighborhood coffee shop, and your laptop or iPhone is telling anybody with a network scanner that you?ve got a hidden network at your house or job." http://windows7forums.com/security-zone/49256-debunking-myths-hiding-your-wireless-ssid-really-more-secure.html WP7 doesn't support this out of the box because it is a bad feature anyway.
Posted by: Luis 07 Nov 2010
Oh come on!
MS did this on purpose, I was hoping that win7 phone would do a few things, one bring more apps to ZuneHD, nope the platform is separate. Two bring WPA-Enterprise to ZuneHD, see #1 and 2 no, seems like win7 phone doesn't support all Wi-Fi security features either. We have nearly 100 APs in my network and no concentrator I'd have to reconfigure all of them by hand (simply: put no) This is an unfortunate area where the iPhone and iPod touch shine. All we need is AD/Exchange integration and some good admin apps and I'd love it. There are some things you can control via group policies of AD 2003 in win7 and you can send it a wireless profile but you can not control if it connects to a non-broadcasting network. MS knows this doesn't offer protection and actually makes all clients of that network send out the name its looking for, however it doesn't matter if MS likes this practice or not, forcing people to either have their AP reveal the network name instead of the clients not a decision forced by devices. Heck I have several network that I visit with my ZuneHD and I found it a pain in the butt to wait till I got there to type in all the hex keys at each place, I'd loved to load it when I was initially setting it up. Its a good product MS just needs to stop hindering it.
Posted by: Stu 19 Oct 2010
A big if.....
"if Windows Phone 7 handsets prove anywhere near as popular as Apple's iPhone." 1. Hahahaha 2. Hahahaha 3. Corporate IT shouldn't let personal devices on the network if they are worried about security. 4. Hahahaha, sorry. Thanks for the Monday smile. Encroute HD2 Windows 6.5 User
Posted by: Séan 18 Oct 2010
Broadcast
Not broadcasting your SSID will not effectively hide your network from determined prying eyes; However it is good practice to do so, especially in a large corporate working environment. I wonder if this was an oversight on Microsoft's part or deliberate!?
Posted by: Carl Dean 15 Oct 2010