Police make Oink founder squeal
/v3-uk/news/2002340/police-oink-founder-squeal
25 Oct 2007, Iain Thomson , V3
The founder of the file sharing site Oink, who was arrested by police on Tuesday, is insisting that he has done nothing wrong in setting up and running the operation.
Alan Ellis, an IT consultant, set up the site over three years ago and when it was shut down it had 180,000 registered users who were able to download music via Bittorrent. The site was renowned for releasing albums ahead of the release date, which aroused the ire of the recording industry.
"Pre-release leaks are one of the most damaging forms of internet piracy that is currently eroding legitimate sales of music across the world," said the British Phonographic Industry.
"Recorded music sales fell by more than a third internationally in the last six years, and independent studies show that a major factor in this decline has been internet users accessing peer-to-peer networks to steal music online."
The site was shut down after an investigation by Interpol, with the site's server in Amsterdam being raided by police at the same time as Ellis was arrested. Ellis is protesting his innocence, saying he has done nothing wrong.
"When I set up the site I didn’t think I was doing anything illegal and I still don’t," he told the Daily Telegraph.
"I don’t sell music to people, I just direct them to it. If somebody wants to illegally download music they are going to do it whether my site is there or not. If this goes to court it is going to set a huge precedent. It will change the internet as we know it."
"As far as I am aware no-one in Britain has ever been taken to court for running a website like mine. My site is no different to something like Google. If Google directed someone to a site they can illegally download music from they are doing the same as I have been accused of."
Police are now analysing the site's records to see who was downloading material and haven't confirmed if they will be taking further action. Visitors to the site now get the following message:
"This site has been closed as a result of a criminal investigation by IFPI, BPI, Cleveland Police and the Fiscal Investigation Unit of the Dutch Police into suspected illegal music distribution. A criminal investigation continues into the identities and activities of the site’s users."
Do you agree?
Is this legal?
Leaking of pre-release versions of albums - now that wouldn't originate from within the music industry itself would it? And perhaps provide a useful service for new bands, showcasing their material to people who then go out and spread the word, leading to increased sales?
No, I thought not.
Once again these 'guardians of the music industry' spout the same old rhetoric and go after the easy target, rather than tackling the problem within the industry itself - if indeed there IS such a problem.
www.oink.cd
And what legal right do the ifpi and the bpi have to put up the page that they have (complete with their logos) on someone else's website?
Posted by DJ Enks, 25 Oct 2007
Impound Google Servers!
I am looking forward to the head of Google UK being arrested and all the Google servers hosted in Europe being impounded. Then I guess the police will trawl through them (Including Gmail?) for signs that users of Google have been doing illigal things.
Posted by Andy, 25 Oct 2007
Nonsense
This is yet another blow to the freedom of the internet. Until we realize the impossibility of virtual ownership, our world will only become more and more competitive, and less and less caring. Must we still fight amongst ourselves? Are we no better than apes?
Posted by Anonymous, 25 Oct 2007