Alan Stevens
Alan Stevens

Bluetooth faces a quicker rival

Ultra Wideband wireless promises fast, short-range communications with good security

Alan Stevens

Everyone knows that recent advances in wireless communication offer business benefits, but there is far less agreement on the underlying technologies and standards, and this can make life very confusing for buyers.

Now there is yet another wireless technology for IT professionals to analyse and worry over, known as Ultra Wideband or UWB.

UWB differs from other wireless architectures in that it isn't restricted to using a single waveband. It transmits streams of extremely short energy pulses, typically around 10 to 1,000 picoseconds, which can be spread across a broad range of frequencies.

The power levels needed for UWB are very low, even lower than those for mobile phones, which is a real advantage when it comes to mobility and battery life. Added to which the broad frequency spread makes UWB very resistant to interference. It can also carry a huge amount of data - potential bandwidth is quoted in hundreds of megabits per second, making it a lot faster than Bluetooth at 2Mbit/s, and the latest 54Mbit/s Wi-Fi standards.

Security is less of a problem with UWB as the short pulses are far harder to intercept, but range remains an issue. Signals can travel no more than around 10 to 20 metres, which effectively rules UWB out as a rival to the 802.11 WLAN technologies.

It could, though, sound the death knell for Bluetooth, not least because of the involvement of Intel, which is championing a new Wireless USB interface, based on UWB, that is expected in 2005. With support for the same 480Mbit/s rate as USB 2.0, but without cables, this could leave Bluetooth trailing.

Elsewhere developers are planning to use UWB to link everything and anything, from PDAs and mobile phones to domestic DVD players and TV sets. It could also be used to link medical probes to monitoring equipment and in covert security and surveillance systems. In fact, wherever a cable is moving large amounts of data, UWB could be used instead. As with all new technologies, however, there are one or two hurdles to overcome first.

Regulatory approval is one. The FCC in the US, for example, has only authorised limited use of UWB across a fixed set of frequencies. Another concerns signal modulation. Two rival techniques are being proposed. One, direct sequence code-division multiple access (DS-CDMA), is borrowed from the cellular world. The other is orthogonal frequency division modulation (OFDM), as used in fixed frequency 802.11a/g WLAN products. Motorola is the big name behind DS-CDMA, supported by a couple of others. Intel, Samsung, Texas Instruments and others are pushing for OFDM. Neither has so far garnered enough support to become part of the proposed IEEE 802.15.3a standard for UWB, effectively stalling the specification. Despite this, Motorola is pressing ahead with product development while the OFDM proponents have formed their own special interest group, the Multiband-OFDM Alliance.

No doubt it will all be sorted out in the end, but in the meantime it might be a good idea to keep those cables for just a little longer.

  • Have your say
  • Send to a friend
  • Print
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • Share

Tags:

Do you agree?

Further reading

Smooth upgrade path for Bluetooth users

Bluetooth to include UWB in future specs

Combined wireless standard to 'prevent confusion'

Business mobility

Business mobility

Mobile working promises to dramatically increase productivity, but European managers and IT departments are dragging their feet

No wireless at Westminster, MPs told

Threat of 'bluesnarfing' attacks prompts wireless ban until security can be guaranteed

Bluetooth bites into the mainstream

Wireless technology taking off as sales of enabled mobiles, PDAs and headsets soar

Related white papers

Related jobs

Most watched

Nokia N8

Nokia N8 video demo

Handset maker gives an early look at its first Symbian^3 smartphone

Motorola Milestone 2

Motorola Milestone 2 video demo

Android 2.2 comes to Milestone line

Analysis and Reports

Storage-as-a-Service: Best efforts or best practice?
IDG research: IT professionals understand the fundamentals of managing and protecting data, but do not apply best practices

The seven security myths of Microsoft Windows 7
It is essential to separate myth from reality about the built-in security of Microsoft’s latest offering

Poll

VMworld 2010 poll

VMworld 2010 poll

How advanced is your firm's cloud computing strategy?

View poll results

White paper library

Attachmate

Smartstream

Keep up to date with the latest products, services and technologies from the world's leading IT companies; IThound.com brings you thousands of white papers, case studies and analyst reports.

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Enter email address to edit your newsletter preferences

Spotlight

Digital Britain

Innovation key to UK broadband take-up

Services like Project Canvas are vital, say experts

Amazon Kindle 3

Amazon Kindle 3 e-book reader review

Amazon trims the size and price of its newest Kindle,...

sas logo

SAS offers easy-to-use predictive analytics

Rapid Predictive Modeler designed to aid enterprise decision making

First impressions of Huawei's Ideos handset

Huawei's Ideos smartphone, announced today , is claimed by the...

Primary Navigation